Why Did PZZA Go Down?

Despite being one of the world’s most famous pizza brands, Papa John’s has recently had to navigate it’s way through a series of macroeconomic and sector-specific challenges.

However, by laying out a clear focus on global expansion and product innovation, the company has developed a strategy that serves as a fascinating case study for businesses operating post lockdowns.

Indeed, the pizza giant’s experiences underscore the importance of resilience and responsive adaptation in the face of change, offering valuable insights for organizations grappling with the currents of a rapidly evolving marketplace.

Therefore, let’s delve deeper into the firm’s business and see where the story of Papa John’s is instructive, not just for those in the food industry but for any enterprise seeking to understand how to thrive in a rapidly changing commercial climate.

Multiple Headwinds Have Stunted Papa John’s Growth

One of the key challenges that PZZA faces today is a significant shift in customer behavior since the reopening of the economy after the coronavirus crisis.

For instance, during the pandemic, the company benefited from a surge in online food delivery orders as lockdowns and government-mandated restrictions conspired to keep people indoors. However, as businesses reopened and mobility increased, the population began spending less time at home. This led to fewer pizza orders, resulting in a slowdown in Papa John’s sales growth.

In addition to changes in consumer habits, the company has had to contend with the issue of tough comparisons, with the firm experiencing a surge in sales during the pandemic setting a high bar for later years. Consequently, annual growth in 2022 came in at just 0.7% compared to the 17.6% it clocked in 2020.

Another notable headwind for Papa John’s has been its decision to stick with its premium pricing strategy. The company’s pizzas and other food items are typically priced higher than other large pizza chain peers, but, as the economy reopened and inflation set in, diners became more price-sensitive and began opting for more affordable food delivery options instead.

Moreover, inflation has directly impacted the corporation by increasing costs for commodities and labor. While PZZA has implemented price increases to cover these rising input costs, the benefits of those increases have been limited due to the decline in guest traffic.

Internationally, the company has seen a 6% decline in revenue numbers due to continued economic pressure in the UK, which, as its second-largest market outside the US, has adversely affected its overall sales growth.

Poor Margins and a Toxic Balance Sheet

The company has been facing a decrease in several of its crucial financial measures recently, and although the firm’s stock had a satisfactory period during the initial months of the year, its challenges have been accumulating ever since.

Similarly, another concern for Papa John’s is its inadequate profitability due to the escalating expenses associated with food and labor. For instance, North American commissary revenues were up 14.2% at $108.3 million, with cheese, wheat, soy oil, and proteins seeing price rises in line with rising inflation. This has had the knock-on effect of dampening its trailing twelve-month gross margin to 30.2%, somewhat lower than the Consumer Discretionary sector median of 35.2%.

Perhaps more worrying, however, is the uptick in the business’s debt burden. The company saw a massive year-on-year increase of $269 million from $528 million in the first quarter of 2022 to $797 million today.

Avenues For Improvement

Regardless of the problems that Papa John’s might face, the company still has a robust growth strategy focused on expanding its global footprint. Having opened 244 net new units (excluding Russia) in 2022 – and with plans to accelerate this in the current year by opening 270-310 additional stores – PZZA’s aggressive expansion plan clearly indicates the company’s commitment to growth and market penetration.

In fact, the company has set a target of reaching 1,400 to 1,800 net new units by the end of 2025, which implies an annual new unit growth of 6% to 8% between 2023-2025. To support this target, the company has a blueprint for new restaurant growth in international markets.

For instance, Papa John’s recently signed a deal with one of its largest international franchisees to expand into two new countries and add 100 new restaurants. Moreover, it has just announced that it is extending its relationship with PJP Investments to build 650 restaurants in India before 2033.

This venture into new territories provides the company with an opportunity to tap into novel customer bases, reducing its reliance on any one single market.

In addition to unit growth, PZZA is also focusing on a revamped menu to drive sales growth. The company has a pipeline of excellent product ideas to be launched throughout 2023, and while the effectiveness of these innovations may be limited in the current inflationary environment, they can attract clientele and spur income generation over the long term.

Why Did PZZA Go Down?

Although the trajectory of Papa John’s growth curve is weighed down by various headwinds, the company is steering towards a promising strategic shift which underscores a transformative journey that many businesses find themselves undertaking in a post-pandemic world.

While its underlying performance metrics may have stalled for the moment, it’s important to note that the company’s aggressive global expansion and commitment to menu innovation show clear signs of a forward-thinking outlook. Rather than allowing temporary setbacks to define its narrative, Papa John’s is carving a path of opportunity from the crux of its challenges.

As the company continues to explore fresh markets and broaden its range of products, it’s also charting a course for expansion and adaptability in uncertain circumstances. Moreover, with an unyielding dedication to its objectives and a profound comprehension of market forces, Papa John’s could potentially position itself for a robust resurgence.

---

The author has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. Financhill has a disclosure policy. This post may contain affiliate links or links from our sponsors.