If you’re new to investing, choosing the right type of broker can feel overwhelming so where should you begin?
When comparing full-service brokers and discount brokers the differences are well worth paying attention to before you open an account and deposit your money, so what exactly are they?
What is a Full-Service Broker?
You can think of a full-service broker as being akin to a personal financial assistant for your investments in the sense that they provide a wide range of services that include personalized investment advice, retirement planning, estate planning, and tax strategies.
Generally, you can build a close relationship with your account manager or representative who will guide your financial journey.
The key features of full-service broker are:
- Personalized Service: You get tailored advice based on your goals.
- Broad Offerings: Access to stocks, bonds, mutual funds, options, and even alternative investments like real estate. You may even get access to private equity deals and pre-IPO stocks.
- Human Touch: Dedicated advisors to connect with and who you can call or meet in person.
- Higher Costs: Fees are typically higher, often charged as commissions or a percentage of your assets.
Pay close attention to these fees, particularly those as a percentage of assets because 1% a year can quickly add up over time. And remember, you are taking 100% of the risk, so treat your money with care and preserve capital where possible. Or in other words, consider negotiating a fixed fee instead of a percentage of assets.
What is a Discount Broker?
Discount brokers offers simpler, no-frills products and services, for the most part. Most will provide you with the tools and platforms you need to trade on your own, but if you’re looking for personal financial advice or planning services you’ll generally need to look elsewhere.
The key features of discount broker are:
- Flat fees or commission-free trading for stocks and ETFs are common.
- You make your own decisions without professional advice.
- Comprehensive online platforms with tools for research and analysis.
- Limited support with little to no human interaction or personalized guidance.
How Does a Full Service & Discount Broker Work?
At a full-service broker you will generally meet with a broker or advisor to discuss your financial goals and then craft a financial plan where your broker recommends investments and even handles the trades for you. Typically, you will get ongoing support, including regular portfolio reviews and market updates.
On the other hand, at a discount broker, you will be responsible for opening an account on their online platform. There you can use tools and resources, such as charts and data to decide what to buy or sell. You can also execute trades directly through their app or website.
How Do You Pick The Right Broker?
- Figure Out What You Need
- If you’re a beginner and want guidance, a full-service broker might very well be worth the extra cost.
- If you’re skilled at researching and managing your own portfolio, go for a discount broker.
- Consider Your Budget
- Full-service brokers charge higher fees, such as 1-2% of assets or per-trade commissions.
- Discount brokers are more cost-effective and often charge no commissions for basic trades.
- Think About Time
- Want to be hands-off? Full-service brokers handle your portfolio and planning on your behalf.
- Prefer hands-on control? Discount brokers are your go-to.
What Are The Pros and Cons of Each Broker?
Full-Service Brokers offer personalized financial advice, and are ideal for complex situations, such as estate or tax planning. They often feature access to exclusive investment too, such as mezzanine debt.
The cons of full service brokers include high costs that can eat into your returns and the fact that some brokers may may push products to earn commissions. Keep in mind that you’re also relying heavily on someone else’s judgment.
On the other hand discount brokers feature the benefits of cost savings due to lower fees as well as greater control over your investment decisions, so they tend to be ideal for tech-savvy investors who value independence.
The disadvantage of discount brokers is the risk of making uninformed decisions without advice and how overwhelming it can be for beginners unfamiliar with the market. You also have limited support if you do need help.
What Are The Best Practices To Pick a Broker?
For a full-service broker, research the firm and, in particular, any advisor with whom you are working. Ensure also that their fees align with the value they provide. Remember your portfolio net worth needs to overcome the cost of the service provided to you.
It’s easy for forget about hidden fees, so make sure to ask what they may be and don’t blindly trust recommendations without understanding them.
Typically, full-service brokers are best for wealth management and family trusts.
For discount brokers, educate yourself on investing basics and feel free to use the free tools and resources provided by the platform but don’t jump into trades without proper research nor ignore risk management, such as appropriate diversification.
Discount brokers are often ideal for day trading or algorithmic strategies with advanced tools.
Who Is the Ideal Client For Each Broker?
Consider Sarah, a busy professional, as an ideal client for a full-service broker. Sarah’s advisor creates a portfolio that combines her goals for retirement and college savings for her kids. For the sake of argument imagine that she pays 1% annually yet values the peace of mind of the high-touch service she receives.
On the other hand, Jake, a tech-savvy millennial, uses a discount broker app to invest in low-cost ETFs. He saves thousands in fees by managing his portfolio himself and really enjoys looking at charts and exploring financial statements in his spare time.
In practice, full-service brokers tend to be less popular among younger investors who prefer cheaper, DIY options while discount brokers have boomed with platforms like Robinhood, WeBull, and Schwab offering commission-free trades.
#1 Stock For The Next 7 Days
When Financhill publishes its #1 stock, listen up. After all, the #1 stock is the cream of the crop, even when markets crash.
Financhill just revealed its top stock for investors right now... so there's no better time to claim your slice of the pie.
See The #1 Stock Now >>The author has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. Financhill has a disclosure policy. This post may contain affiliate links or links from our sponsors.