Dividends vs Share Buybacks: Which Is Better For Investors?

In fact, some of the most common ways of enticing potential backers are to pay out dividends and buy back stock.

Indeed, these actions signal to the market that an enterprise is in a healthy place, and that capital invested in the venture is insulated somewhat from the formation of any onerous economic developments.

But what are the pros and cons of each of these methods? And which is the best from a shareholder’s perspective?

What Is A Dividend?

At its most basic level, a dividend is a payment a company makes to some or all of its investors.

As one such investor, you may be eligible to receive these payments if you own the correct type of shares and the company is performing well financially.

In fact, enterprises commonly distribute a portion of their earnings to shareholders, provided they possess surplus cash after settling their financial obligations. This custom is especially prevalent among large, well-established firms that yield substantial profits and have no requirement to plow back the proceeds into the company.

Since investors have numerous avenues through which to allocate their funds, a robust payout can sway their decision on where to put their money whilst bolstering a company’s stock price.

As compensation, shareholders receive a welcome dividend, which, over time, can enhance their overall profits and provide a steady source of reliable income.

Do All Companies Pay Dividends?

Not all corporations choose to pay a dividend. For instance, certain firms need to be more profitable and require maximum financing to expand and improve their bottom line. Moreover, while some of these operations may be profitable, they may still prefer to prioritize growth endeavors over giving cash to investors in the form of dividends.

That said, firms that refrain from dispensing dividends are only sometimes less attractive as investment alternatives. Certain companies in a phase of rapid expansion may witness a more significant percentage rise in their stock price than a more established company could ever offer in dividend returns. In fact, investors in these types of companies can realize returns on their investments by dispensing their shares and taking the already accrued capital.

What Are The Advantages Of Issuing And Receiving Dividends?

Dividend payouts play a significant role in diminishing the overall risk and instability of a portfolio.

Indeed, with respect to risk reduction, dividends will often alleviate any losses stemming from a decrease in overall stock prices.

However, the risk-mitigating benefits of dividends extend beyond this fundamental fact.

Historically, researchers have demonstrated that stocks that pay dividends outperform those that do not during bouts of economic contraction.

Although a general slump typically affects stocks across the board, stocks that offer dividends usually experience a substantially lower decrease in value compared to those that do not.

In fact, an essential aspect of investing in the stock market is market uncertainty, which pertains to the inherent risk linked to any equity investment. Stocks can experience both gains and losses, and there is no assurance that they will increase in worth.

While investing in companies that offer dividends does not guarantee profits, dividend stocks provide a degree of return on investment that is practically assured. Likewise, it is exceedingly uncommon for dividend-paying firms with a reputation for such distributions to discontinue making their payments, and, in reality, most of these companies take pride in increasing the size of their dividends as time goes on.

Share buybacks: How Do They Work?

In addition to offering their stakeholders a dividend, companies can also return value to investors through a mechanism known as a share buyback.

A share buyback – or stock repurchase program – happens when a business purposefully buys back its shares through the open market or a fixed-price tender offer.

Why Do Companies Repurchase Their Stock?

Since companies obtain capital by issuing shares, it may appear bizarre to want to return that money once it’s safely ensconced in the bank.

Nonetheless, there are pertinent motives to compel a company to buy back its shares.

For example, stock repurchases lessen the number of shareholders, aiding the firm in consolidating ownership. Each share denotes a percentage of the underlying company and grants the holder a voice on critical matters and sway within the firm. Ultimately, the company may choose to reduce the number of shareholders to curtail this external influence.

Furthermore, if a company’s valuation is plummeting too rapidly, it may choose – or be forced – to repurchase its shares. In such cases, the business can attempt to elevate or temporarily halt the decline by generating demand for the stock, which drives up the price per share. However, this improvement is transitory unless the company can reverse its predicament.

On top of that, another significant reason for firms to undertake a share buyback is their conviction that they are genuinely undervalued. Undervaluation may arise from various causes, often attributed to investors’ incapacity to overlook a company’s short-term performance or a general pessimistic mood permeating the market.

Indeed, after a period of economic stagnation, numerous companies make enthusiastic predictions for the upcoming years, even though their stock prices still mirror the woes that had afflicted them previosuly. These companies can therefore reinvest in themselves by buying back their shares, anticipating that they will profit when prices begin to reflect the actual, real underlying market conditions.

Finally, publicly traded corporations encounter demands to sustain quarterly payouts once they begin dispensing dividends to shareholders.

Nevertheless, the company must balance its duties to stockholders with its financial requirements. If the economy were to plunge into a recession, say, the company might be required to curtail the extent of the dividend payment, thereby causing a market sell-off.

However, rather than reducing dividends, the company can reduce the number of shares it repurchases, which would assuage investors’ anxieties. This lends it a degree of flexibility that isn’t as quickly exercised when the primary way of returning value is through a cash distribution.

There’s No Such Thing As Free Money

Despite the advantages associated with stock repurchases and dividend payments, the benefits do not come without a cost. Both must be financed from the company’s own source of wealth, either with its retained earnings or, in the case of buybacks, through debt or excess cash from operations.

In each of these scenarios, money is being taken from the business and diverted into other ends, which may deprive the enterprise of funds necessary in other domains, such as research and development or investments into novel products and infrastructure.

There are also other risks involved as well.

In fact, if you invest in a company with a worryingly inflated dividend payout ratio, this can carry a certain degree of danger you may not be accustomed to.

For example, the fraction of a company’s earnings paid out to shareholders instead of being reserved for debt reduction, reinvestment in growth, or as a cash cushion is reflected in this most vital of financial yardsticks.

For many companies, deciding the appropriate amount to distribute to shareholders is a delicate balancing act. They aim to offer high payouts to attract and retain investors while still holding enough of their earnings to support future expansion as well as the potential to increase the dividend itself.

However, when a company’s dividend payout ratio becomes too high to be sustainable, it may be forced to cut or eliminate its dividend altogether.

There are similar issues with share buybacks too. Indeed, over the last ten years, interest rates have cratered to levels rarely ever seen, resulting in an inexpensive cost of borrowing for businesses eager to take advantage.

Regardless, there are concerns among some analysts that a majority of recent buybacks have been financed through debt, which could result in excessive leverage on the balance sheets of vulnerable companies.

Dividends vs Share Buybacks: The Bottom Line

Dividends are a time-tested way to receive passive income from a qualifying investment. However, they are not necessarily guaranteed and may leave a company short of cash in the near term.

Alternatively, buybacks typically increase the capital gains acquired from a stock’s share price appreciation but are only valuable once an investor sells their stake in the firm.

#1 Stock For The Next 7 Days

When Financhill publishes its #1 stock, listen up. After all, the #1 stock is the cream of the crop, even when markets crash.

Financhill just revealed its top stock for investors right now... so there's no better time to claim your slice of the pie.

See The #1 Stock Now >>